Legacy Cakery - Small Jars. Big Flavor.
  • Home
  • ABOUT
    • OUR STORY
    • Blog
    • FAQ
    • Newsletter
    • Contact Us
  • CAKE JARS
    • Mini Cake Jars
    • Large Cake Jars
    • Cake Jar Flavors
    • Jars For The Occasions

cake menu

Home >  Cake Menu

cake menu

Thank you for your interest in Legacy Cakery . We're so happy you're here! Below you'll find a list of our most popular flavors. Our flavors and filling lists are unlimited, if you don't see it please still inquire about it! All cakes are baked fresh and customized for your order. You can mix and match cake flavors and fillings to create your own special creation. When you're ready to inquire about an order, submit your cake order request here.

*Quick note: Please allow ALL orders 3-5 weeks advance notice
​​

Legacy Cakery Prices & Flavors

Popular Flavors
  • Lemon
  • Chocolate
  • Vanilla
  • Strawberry
  • Red Velvet/Blue Velvet
  • Marble

Popular Specialty Flavors
  • German
  • Carrot
  • Pumpkin Spice
  • Pistachio
  • Chocolate Chip
  • Coconut 
  • Death by Chocolate
  • Strawberry Shortcake
  • Pineapple

Popular Fillings
Fresh Fruit or Fruit preserve
  • Strawberry
  • Blueberry
  • Raspberry
  • Pineapple
  • Guava

Popular Buttercream
  • Vanilla chocolate
  • Mocha
  • Oreo
  • Peanut butter
  • Oreo Cream Cheese
  • Cream Cheese

Popular Mousse
  • Chocolate Mousse
  • White Chocolate Mousse
  • Vanilla creme’ mousse
  • Peanut butter Mousse
  • Chocolate Cream cheese

Cupcakes
Prices listed below are starting cupcake prices, your final cost will vary depending on the details of your order
STARTING at:
  • Mini - $2.00
  • Standard - $3.00
  • Speciality- $4.00
  • Liquor Infused - $5.00 (must be ordered by the dozen)
  • Giant Cupcake- (Serve 10-15) $45
  • Cupcake Cake-

Cake
Tiered Cakes 4” high filled
Cake Prices listed below are STARTING prices, your final cost will vary depending on the details of your order
Round Square
  • 6 inch       Serves 12-18  $45    
  • 8 inch       Serves 24-30  $55  
  • 9 inch       Serves 32-38  $75   
  • 10 inch     Serves 38-42  $95   

Sheet Cakes
One Layer filled Cake
  • 1/4            Serves 24 $50
  • 1/2            Serves 50 $100
  • Full           Serves 96 $200

Edible Images start at $20
Personalize your cake with your own image
*images must be sent 2 week in advance prior to pick-up and must be in J-peg format*

For Custom designs, Fondant and Large Tiered Cake, please Call or Email all inquiries: [email protected]


Use And Care
Our cake and cupcakes 
arrive frozen to guarantee freshness. Before serving, please let cakes stand at room temperature for 3-4 hours. Do not refrigerate or refreeze Legacy Cakery cakes or cupcakes. Legacy Cakery makes everything fresh from scratch using only the finest ingredients. 

50% deposit is required of all orders prior to pick-up

Delivery of Cakes are available for
  • 20 mile radius -$35
  • 20+ miles radius - starting at $45
  • Out of State,  SI and Bx deliveries will be subjected to toll cost as well as starting fee. *Orders over $800 delivery is FREE

Prices are subject to change at anytime without notice
ALL DEPOSITS are non refundable!!
Care Instruction PDF
cake_care_instructions.pdf
File Size: 830 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

Cake Order Form | JARS For Occasions Form | FAQs | Reviews
NEWSLETTER
Join the club that's all about sweetness!
Get access to exclusive deals, recipes, and behind-the-scenes bakery life delivered right to your inbox.
SUBSCRIBE

ABOUT
Our Story
Blog
Reviews

VIP Member

SHOP
Cake Jars
mini Cake Jars
​Large Cake Jars
Cake Jars Flavors

Jars for Occasions ​

HELP
Track Your Order
Shipping Policy ​
​
FAQs
Contact

CONNECT WITH US

White circular logo for Legacy Cakery featuring a jar of cake with a spoon and the tagline “Small Jars. Big Flavor.” on a transparent background.
© 2025 LEGACY CAKERY, LLC. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy | Terms and Conditions | ​Website Design New Jersey - Rodney Creatives
We proudly accept
Picture
  • Home
  • ABOUT
    • OUR STORY
    • Blog
    • FAQ
    • Newsletter
    • Contact Us
  • CAKE JARS
    • Mini Cake Jars
    • Large Cake Jars
    • Cake Jar Flavors
    • Jars For The Occasions